|
It's
an ugly subject. It shouldn't exist. It's one of those taboo issues
we like to sweep under the rug, ignore, and pretend doesn't happen.
Unfortunately, abuse of the elderly, like abuse of women or children,
is a fact of life which might be increasing throughout the world.
"Abuse
takes one of four forms," explained professor of social work,
Howie Litwin. "There is physical abuse, the 'battered grandma
syndrome,' which includes blows, burns or even restraints, such
as tying a patient to his chair or gagging him."
There
is also psychological abuse, which includes threatening, shaming
or frightening an elderly person. The threat of abandoning an
older person or sending him to an old aged home, can be a form
of abuse. The third kind of abuse is material abuse. This refers
to extortion, exploitation or deceit, for example, cheating an
old man out of his rights or getting him to invest in bogus projects.
Finally, the fourth form of abuse is neglect, both passive and
active--forgetting to bathe or feed a dependent patient, administering
the wrong medicine and withholding heat in the winter if he's
freezing. These are all forms psychological abuse.
Abuse
against the elderly is not easily revealed.
|
| There
seems to be a "conspiracy of silence" in which the
victims themselves are active participants. |
|
Some elderly abused people are afraid to admit the extent of their
suffering or are embarrassed to let strangers know especially
when a child or spouse is the aggressor. Some believe that they
"have it coming to them." Others take a fatalistic approach
("Who cares anyway," or "What good will it do to
complain."). Even if the victim complains, his story is not
always understood or believed. "He's paranoid" or "He's
a bit demented" are labels easily attributed to the distraught
or incoherent elderly person.
Professionals
are also loath to "rock the boat." In the emergency
ward battered grannies are often returned to their homes by overworked
staff who don't want to "get involved," aren't sure
that there's something suspicious about the broken bones or black
and blue marks, and don't want to get "stuck" with an
aging patient who has nowhere to go. Moreover, the police claim
their hands are tied if there is no complaint lodged by a victim.
Yet anyone who discovers a case of abuse against the elderly and
does nothing about it, is actually assisting the continuation
of a criminal act.
Abuse
of the elderly is not limited to the home. Unfortunately, more
and more cases of abuse are coming to light in institutions. Here
too, there are examples of physical aggression against inmates,
cases of extortion when a staff member demands or hints at a tip.
But much more common are the instances of neglect. Incontinent
nursing patients who aren't changed or turned regularly in bed
and so develop painful pressure sores are at one end of the spectrum,
whereas residents wheeled into an activity room and left there
facing a blank wall throughout the program are at the other end.
The
staff in many nursing homes are overworked and underpaid and thus
develop a low patience and frustration threshold. They can easily
"forget" to answer a patient's call for help, or, even
worse, turn on him in anger and shout, "You're a real pest,
you know. Why are you always ringing the bell!" It is often
difficult to pin responsibility on a particular aide as there
are changing shifts every day and many family members, even if
they are in the picture, are loath to complain. After all they
have few options and are even afraid of reprisals if they report
their suspicions of neglect or abuse to the director. The fear
that the director might say, "If you don't like it here,
you can always take your parent out," prevents family members
from expressing criticism.
The
elderly do not initially perceive some forms of abuse as such
themselves. Widows are often relieved of their savings by smooth-talking
exploiters who promise them marriage, companionship and everlasting
devotion -- which lasts as long as there is still money in the
bank.
"White
angels" often come into the lives of lonely and dependent
old people, running errands for them, doing favors, and gradually
becoming indispensable. Not surprisingly these one-time strangers
later appear in the wills of their victims, and sometimes, even
before the wills are read, acquire rights to the property or money
of the old people they assist "out of the goodness of their
hearts." These cases of exploitation are difficult to prosecute
because the elderly are often willing to "buy" companionship,
cooperating fully and knowingly with the extortionist.
|
| Most
crimes against the elderly occur in the family setting. |
|
The
most repulsive form remains physical violence. It appears in all
socio-economic groups. There are certain generalities that one
can make about the nature of the abused and the abusers in this
age group. Most abusers were themselves brutalized, either as
children or as wives, and learned to hit rather than communicate
from the very parents or husband they now mistreat. Furthermore,
the aggressor and the victim generally live together. Many of
the abusers suffer from psychiatric illness, are substance abusers,
and are overwhelmed by financial or family problems. The onus
of caring for a dependent, often an elderly invalid, who has constant
demands and does not let the caregiver sleep, is itself a source
of pent-up frustration and stress which can lead to abuse.
The correct approach to abuse, according to the experts on the
subject, is to give attention to the needs of the aggressor, as
well as to those of the victim. "Whereas we cannot condone
attack on a defenseless old person, resolution of the problem
requires more than blaming the offender," said one gerontologist.
"The perpetuator is as much a victim of unfortunate circumstances
as the object of his abuse, and indeed, many abusers are horrified
at their behavior but seem unable to help themselves. They are
often under a great deal of stress, either due to life crisis
or the worry and unbending weight of caring for their dependent
relative.
"Crimes
without villains" is how many experts refer to the phenomenon
of elderly abuse in the home. Professionals must intervene on
three levels:
1.) Crisis intervention must provide immediate protective measures,
e.g. shelters or protected housing for the elderly at risk;
2.) Counseling for the abuser to help them gain self awareness
and learn means of control;
3.) Alleviation of common family and social problems that may
accelerate family tension and lead to abuse in the home. This
means obtaining assistance from formal and informal networks and
discovering what rights and services exist to alleviate the pressure.
Thus,
even as society must protect the abused and make arrangements
that will enhance their lives and care in the future, in most
cases those who abuse are themselves tormented and miserable and
in need of professional assistance and counseling. Greater awareness
of the problem and increased sensitivity to both the victims and
their tormentors should bring about a change in this most odious
social situation and will lead, hopefully, to a decrease in abuse.
|