Bright, Demanding
Five-Year-Old

Q: My 5-year-old granddaughter is very bright and uses sophisticated language. Consequently, when her mom tries to correct her, she will ask her mother (my daughter), "Well, I've picked up toys, and I gave my brother a snack, and now what are you going to do for me, Mom?" My daughter says it's become difficult to discipline my granddaughter. Her husband says their daughter needs to be spanked when she gets bossy and demanding. We have all contributed to her bad behavior by letting her hear us praise her as to how smart she is. Can you help us with this dilemma?

  
 

A: An appropriate response to your granddaughter's comment might be, "I'm going to say, 'Thank you very much for being such a good helper,' and I would appreciate your help even more if you didn't ask for anything in return. Then I would know you were truly a kind girl." Verbally gifted children are easily given too much power or praise, but your granddaughter can't be faulted for that. Once a child is given too much power, it isn't easily taken away and a spanking is only likely to make her angry and more defiant.

It also sounds as if her parents disagree about how to handle her, which typically causes children to become insolent. If her mother takes her side against her dad, or vice versa, or if you take the child's side against either parent, it gives her the adult power she wants too early. Furthermore, your granddaughter seems to be learning that negativity attracts the most attention, and in light of the competition she must feel with her little brother, negativity could become her response to feelings of rejection.

As a grandmother, you may wish to introduce your daughter and son-in-law to "The United Front," Chapter Two in my book How To Parent So Children Will Learn. As her parents unite, do be sure to support them rather than contradict them. Also, if you can spend some time alone with your granddaughter once a week playing games, talking, or taking a walk, you might be able to rebuild a positive connection she may miss having with you.

Dr. Sylvia Rimm, Phd

Copyright © 2000, Creators Syndicate, Inc.

 
Dr. Sylvia B. Rimm is a child psychologist, a clinical professor at Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine and the author of many books on parenting. She appears weekly on her own radio show, Family Talk With Sylvia Rimm, and appears monthly on the NBC Today Show.
 
Ask a WholeFamily Expert
 
 
 
WholeFamily Home RegisterParent Center Home Page
Home / Parent Center / Sylvia Rimm

 
RECOMMENDED BOOKS

How to Parent So Children Will Learn

On Raising Kids
 


RELATED ARTICLES 
Foundational Principles of Parenting


Search the Site
ISSUES
Adult Children
Between Mom & Dad
Between Siblings
Child Development
Communication
Discipline/Behavior
Divorce
Fathers and Mothers
Feelings
Friendships
Gifted Kids
Grandparenting
Health & Nutrition
LD/ADHD
Life Changes
Living & Dying
School
Sexuality
Sleep
Substance Abuse
Toilet Learning
TV & Computers
AGES
Early Childhood
School-Age
Teen
COMMUNITIES
Single Parents
Working Moms
Blended (Step)
Families
FEATURES
SYLVIA RIMM, PhD
Dramas
Contests
Crisis Center
Daily Dilemma
Hot Topics
COLUMNS
Reflections from Ruth
Under Sherri's Hat
WholeMom
PERKS
Family Fun
Helpful Hints
Parent Epiphanies

Great Parenting Tips

Wisdom of the Ages
 

Search by
Issue and Age




 
send this page to a friend
 
feedback

 


discipline