Daughter Lacks Compassion

Q: I am the mother of three girls, ages seven, five and a half, and three. My problem lies with my oldest daughter. She cares about no one but herself. If one of her sisters is hurt physically or sad because of something, she offers no compassion towards her. There are situations where they are with other people, and the others have made comments about her lack of compassion.

It is said that children learn by example, and I am not a perfect mother, but I am a very caring person and go beyond the call of duty whenever anyone I care about needs anything. It is even more disturbing to see my daughter be so cold and unaffected by anyone beside herself.

My daughter also gives no respect to her grandparents, aunts or uncles. I constantly prompt her to say "Hello," "Good-bye," "Thank you," or to make eye contact. She is not a shy person. I believe it is just a power struggle. If she is preoccupied, she wants nothing to do with anyone. I seem to have to threaten her with punishments to get her to do these things. If I can't even get her to use basic respect with family members, you can imagine how it is with others. If adults say "Hello" to her, she says nothing. I am just appalled at this.

  
 

A: It seems as if your daughter's problem is a combination of having a less emotional temperament and an attention-getting power struggle. Rather than accelerate the power struggle by punishment, I would suggest you try to coach her.

Try to be understanding about her problem, and ask her how you can help. Two sisters have also dethroned your daughter. You might establish a closer, more positive bond by setting up a weekly date with her. You could go for a walk or to lunch, but it needs to be time for her alone. First children seem to respond to sibling rivalry in more difficult ways than children born later.

Your daughter's stubborn refusal to say hello to her grandparents may be related to feelings of rejection from them. If you can change the battle to an alliance, you may discover that your daughter is indeed in need of a special friendship, which you and her grandparents can provide together.

Dr. Sylvia Rimm, Phd

Copyright © 2000, Creators Syndicate, Inc.

 
Dr. Sylvia B. Rimm is a child psychologist, a clinical professor at Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine and the author of many books on parenting. She appears weekly on her own radio show, Family Talk With Sylvia Rimm, and appears monthly on the NBC Today Show.
 
Ask a WholeFamily Expert
 
 
 
WholeFamily Home RegisterParent Center Home Page
Home / Parent Center / Sylvia Rimm

 
RECOMMENDED BOOKS

How to Parent So Children Will Learn

On Raising Kids
 




Search the Site
ISSUES
Adult Children
Between Mom & Dad
Between Siblings
Child Development
Communication
Discipline/Behavior
Divorce
Fathers and Mothers
Feelings
Friendships
Gifted Kids
Grandparenting
Health & Nutrition
LD/ADHD
Life Changes
Living & Dying
School
Sexuality
Sleep
Substance Abuse
Toilet Learning
TV & Computers
AGES
Early Childhood
School-Age
Teen
COMMUNITIES
Single Parents
Working Moms
Blended (Step)
Families
FEATURES
SYLVIA RIMM, PhD
Dramas
Contests
Crisis Center
Daily Dilemma
Hot Topics
COLUMNS
Reflections from Ruth
Under Sherri's Hat
WholeMom
PERKS
Family Fun
Helpful Hints
Parent Epiphanies

Great Parenting Tips

Wisdom of the Ages
 

Search by
Issue and Age




 
send this page to a friend
 
feedback

 


daughter