Independence Day

  
By Toby Klein Greenwald
Director, WholeFamily Room
 

The first time I saw Independence Day was on video, not in the theater, and I watched it then three times. (In two days.)


Ah, stereotypes. Sometimes they work.

Now, I admit that I am a UFO freak. In my youth, I was a Trekkie. In my adulthood, I am an X-Filer. In between I went to every science fiction film I could get my pocket on. And my students will tell you that one of my favorite teaching films is Close Encounters of a Third Kind. So this is a reviewer with an attitude.

I loved "Independence Day".

Questions for Discussion:
• Who in this film would you most like to be like and why?

• What did you like best about Independence Day?

Read and discuss our WholeFamily film questions…

I loved it because the good guys win, because the special effects are incredible, because nobody smokes cigarettes (though there are lots of cigars), because they risk their lives to save the dog, because a woman drives a truck well, because every type of personality shows up on screen (hopeful New Agers holding signs "Take Me With You", Madison Avenue executives, farm workers, Viet Nam vets, military macho types…), because it doesn't deny real life (people are killed, get divorced, screw up, lie, and yes, there are government coverups…) because every family constellation in America is represented (happily married, single parent, stepfamily…), because it shows that terrorism is bad because people get dead from it, because there are serious value dilemmas (should the president nuke the aliens to save the world if it means nuking Americans in the process?), because the conflicted nations around the globe (Arab, Israeli, Chinese, Russian…) work together to rescue humanity, and most of all, because the world is saved by the combination of a cute and clever WASP president, a flippant gutsy black pilot and a sensitive computer-nerd Jew.

That's what America is all about. Ah, stereotypes. Sometimes they work.

In case those of you who haven't seen the film or the video haven't figured it out, let me sum it up in one sentence. Well, maybe five:

  1. Bad aliens invade the world and threaten to annihilate humanity

  2. Had the CIA not kept information from the president, the invasion might not have been prevented, but it could have been repelled earlier.

  3. Unlike the former CIA official in the movie, the aliens are straightforward and honest. (President: "What do you want us to do?" Alien: "Die.")

  4. The combo I mentioned earlier put their skills together to "dis" the bad guys.

  5. 5) Two out of the three heroes get their woman in the end.

If you want to give yourselves a strong dose of fun, action, off-beat humor and patriotism, prepare a giant bowl of popcorn and carrot sticks and curl up under a warm comforter on a rainy night and watch Independence Day together.

Twice.

 

Ms. Toby Klein Greenwald is Co-President and Director of Creative Development of WholeFamily.com. In her former life she taught film analysis and wrote scripts.
 
Ask a WholeFamily Expert
 
 
 
Home / WholeFamily Room / Film Reviews

Toby Klein Greenwald

ADDITIONAL   RESOURCES  
 
Independence Day
VHS  Format DVD  Format

 


 

Film Board
Film Board

 




Search the Site
 
Real Life Dramas

Family View On Films

Family Soap Opera

Family Treasure Chest

Family RoundTable

Discussion Boards

Heroic Stories

The Family Meeting

 
 
 


Independence Day