Six-Year-Old Doesn't Like Criticism (Who Does?)

Q

Our six-year-old son, who is a middle child, has a very hard time taking criticism. When we scold him for hurting someone accidentally or for bad behavior he gets extremely angry and embarrassed and usually runs off to his room yelling and crying and doesn't want to see us. A short while later, his rage seems to abate, but we're wondering if there is something we can do to help him accept criticism and understand that he needn't be so angry when such things happen.

  
A

Guest Expert Marcia Levine, MA, answers:
 

Many children have rather colorful reactions at this age to correction and to blows to their self-esteem. Your son is at the age when he has internalized your standards; they have become his own. When he does not live up to them, he feels he's not okay, that he's wrong.


Your letter raised a critical issue for parents about criticism as opposed to setting limits and educating. It's useful to remember our own wounded feelings and anger that even the most constructive criticism can cause.

It sounds as though your son feels momentarily overwhelmed by being wrong and by feeling wronged by you, since you are the ones who pointed out his failings. He may not be sure at whom he's angrier -- himself or you -- and whether anger or shame is paramount.

Paradoxically, one way to help children relax their high standards for themselves is to accept anger and shame as legitimate responses. Good people feel ashamed and angry and embarrassed. Your son's reactions sound like an age appropriate response and coping mechanism. As his reactions of anger and embarrassment become more acceptable to you and to him, his self-esteem won't be as damaged by his reactions and he won't need to feel so angry and embarrassed.

Parents often assume that their children should want to be with their parents when they are in the state you described. It's quite legitimate to need some space and recovery time alone. Although parents may often feel somewhat rejected at that point, understanding that it's a real coping mechanism may help lessen parents' own need to go to their children immediately.

In response to their child's anger, parents often will feel bewildered and overwhelmed. But they may be unaware that often they're also angry. This hidden anger often causes a more extreme reaction in the child. So it's useful for parents to identify, legitimize and cope with their anger as well.

Your letter raised a critical issue for parents about criticism as opposed to setting limits and educating. It's useful to remember our own wounded feelings and anger that even the most constructive criticism can cause. Criticism implies there is something wrong with us, not just that we're doing something the wrong way. In this example, the child is scolded for hurting someone accidentally, when there was no intent to hurt. So the criticism and the implied blame may not be useful to whatever educational message you, as parents, meant to convey.

Often, the best time to discuss the message in a non-critical fashion is after the child and/or parents' own anger has abated. It can then be discussed without blaming.

 
Marcia Levine, MA, is a child and adult psychotherapist.
 
Ask a WholeFamily Expert
 

Do you have a child who is NOT sensitive to criticism?

Yes No

 


How would you handle this situation?

Take the Survey!

 

 
WholeFamily Home RegisterParent Center Home Page

Home / Parent Center / Feelings / School Age

 
RECOMMENDED BOOKS

Your Six-Year-Old: Loving and Defiant Your Six-Year-Old



 

 

RELATED ARTICLES 
Eight Year Old Has Separation Anxiety
Eight-Year-Old Gets Morning Stomach Aches
Nine-Year-Old in Love
Life Lessons from Little League


Search the Site
ISSUES
Adult Children
Between Mom & Dad
Between Siblings
Child Development
Communication
Discipline/Behavior
Divorce
Fathers and Mothers
Feelings
Friendships
Gifted Kids
Grandparenting
Health & Nutrition
LD/ADHD
Life Changes
Living & Dying
School
Sexuality
Sleep
Substance Abuse
Toilet Learning
TV & Computers
AGES
Early Childhood
School-Age
Teen
COMMUNITIES
Single Parents
Working Moms
Blended (Step)
Families
FEATURES
SYLVIA RIMM, PhD
Dramas
Contests
Crisis Center
Daily Dilemma
Hot Topics
COLUMNS
Reflections from Ruth
Under Sherri's Hat
WholeMom
PERKS
Family Fun
Helpful Hints
Parent Epiphanies

Great Parenting Tips

Wisdom of the Ages
 

Search by
Issue and Age




 
send this page to a friend
 
feedback

 


child